Makeup Remover.

What you need:

carrier oil
cotton balls
washcloth
warm water

You can mix carrier oils or use one plain. Castor oil is appropriate here if mixed. You probably don't want to use essential oils, to be safer for your eyes.

Instructions:

Soak a bit of oil onto a cotton ball. Start wiping away the makeup. A lot of it will transfer onto the cotton ball, but some will smear on your face. Just keep going until you have it mostly off. I can do both eyes with one cotton ball (I wear a lot of eye makeup), but if you're doing your whole face you'll want to have more.

Get the washcloth damp with warm water and use it to wipe away the oil and the remaining makeup.

At this point I would advise you to splash cold water on your face for the sake of closing your pores.